Compared · ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Mode · checked November 8, 2026
An AI rank tracker asks ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Mode your prompts and records where your brand lands in each answer. But the order of brands in an AI answer barely repeats: SparkToro found two runs list them in the same order less than once in 1,000. Track how often you're recommended instead, with its range.
Want a number that means something on ChatGPT, Perplexity and AI Mode? supereo ours is our pick: it tracks all three, plus Gemini, Claude and AI Overviews, and reports how often each recommends you, with the answer count and 95% range, instead of a rank. $149 a month. Run the free audit.
In a Google result, position 3 means something tomorrow. In an AI answer it often doesn't. SparkToro and Gumshoe had 600 volunteers run 12 prompts 2,961 times and estimated "1 in 1,000 runs before you'd see two lists in the same order"; Rand Fishkin's verdict was that any tool giving "a ranking position in AI" is "full of baloney" (SparkToro, Jan 27, 2026). What held up better in that study was how often a brand appears at all.
The engines don't agree with each other either. In supereo's November 7 run, 28 buyer questions went to ChatGPT, Perplexity, Claude, Gemini and Google AI Mode:
Across all 24 questions where at least two engines named a tool, the engines never all put the same one first. So "you rank #2 in ChatGPT" describes one answer from one engine on one run. A rate, the share of many answers that recommend you, is the number that survives.
Most AI rank trackers do report a position. They define it differently, and the definitions matter.
| Tracker | Its position metric, in its own words | ChatGPT | Perplexity | AI Mode | From / month |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| supereo ours | Leads with how often answers recommend you, a rate with its range | App | API, labeled | Yes | $149 |
| ZipTie.ai | Publishes no position: "a refusal rather than a gap" | Yes | Yes | Yes | About $0.01 a check |
| Otterly.AI | Average brand position: sum of positions ÷ prompts where the brand appeared | Yes | Yes | Add-on | $29 |
| Peec AI | Position: "where you rank when you do appear, compared with other brands" | Yes | Add-on | Yes | $95 |
| SE Visible | Average position in the answers that mention you; position also weights Visibility | Yes | Not listed | Yes | $89 |
| Nightwatch | Average position "within list-based answers provided by LLMs" | Yes | Yes | Yes | €79 |
| AIclicks | Your position among an AI Overview's sources, per keyword | Yes | Marked API | Yes | $59 |
| Profound | Average Position across responses; Position as a ranked score | Trial | Enterprise | Enterprise | Trial, then custom |
| Rankscale | Not defined on the pages we read | Yes | Yes | Yes | $17 yearly |
Sources: each tracker's docs, glossary or pricing page, November 8, 2026. Rankscale's figures from its pricing page read the same day.
Average position usually counts only the answers that name you, as Otterly.AI's formula spells out. That makes it easy to read backwards. Take 20 answers to one question:
| Brand | Answers naming it | Average position | Share of answers naming it | 95% range on that share |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brand A | 2 of 20 | 1.0 | 10% | 0% to 23% |
| Brand B | 16 of 20 | 3.0 | 80% | 62% to 98% |
An illustration, our arithmetic: average position from the named answers only; range ±1.96·√(p(1−p)/n), floored at 0%.
A tracker that leads with average position ranks Brand A first. Any buyer would rather be Brand B. Read position only next to the share of answers, and the share only with its range.
Asks your buyers' questions on ChatGPT and Gemini in their apps, Perplexity and Claude by API, and Google AI Mode and AI Overviews from live results, three times a week each. Every answer is saved with the line that names you, and every rate shows its answer count and range. Method
Best for teams that want a number they can act on, and the work done to move it.
Seven engines, ChatGPT, Perplexity and AI Mode among them, about a cent a check, daily to monthly. "We report a rate, never a rank in ChatGPT", in its own words, with ranges on three headline rates. Methodology
Best for rates with ranges, paying per check.
Ten engines on every plan on credits, from $17 a month billed yearly; Pro is $99 for up to 4,800 answers. Scheduling from hourly to monthly. Pricing
Best for many engines on a small budget.
A Google rank tracker with AI tracking on ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity, AI Mode and AI Overview: 50 AI prompts daily on the €79 Starter, average position and share of voice included. AI tracking
Best for seeing AI positions next to Google positions.
Daily checks on 3 models from $59, recording your position among an AI Overview's sources per keyword; Perplexity is in its model list, marked API. Pricing
Best for per-keyword AI Overview positions on a budget.
Position, visibility and sentiment per prompt, daily, on 3 models you pick; Perplexity is a $35 add-on on Starter ($30 billed yearly). Pricing
Best for team dashboards with position and sentiment.
ChatGPT, Perplexity, Copilot and AI Overviews daily from $29, with a published average-position formula; AI Mode is an add-on. KPI definitions
Best for the cheapest start, with formulas you can check.
ChatGPT, Gemini, AI Mode and AI Overviews through browser sessions, daily, from $89; its Visibility score weights each mention by position. No Perplexity on the plans we read. How it works
Best for position-weighted visibility on many answers.
Public posts, word for word, complaints first. They're individual posts, not reviews or ratings.
“lately every client call ends with someone asking why their "AI ranking" dropped from a tool we're paying for.”u/Klutzy-Pace-9945 on r/DigitalMarketing · Sep 23, 2026 · Read the post
What helpsReport a rate instead of a rank: the share of answers that recommend you, with its range. A one-place move in a list is noise; a rate that clears its range is a change. That's how supereo reports.
“just feels like "you're ranked #3 in ChatGPT" is a made-up number dressed up as a metric.”u/Klutzy-Pace-9945 on r/DigitalMarketing · Sep 23, 2026 · Read the post
What helpsOur November 7 count agrees: in 16 questions where all five engines named a tool, they never put the same one first.
“there's no position 1 to report. the same prompt run twice gives different answers, so any tool selling you a rank number is really selling you a sampled appearance rate over N runs, and the sample size matters more than the interface.”u/AccessFuel on r/SEO_for_AI · Sep 1, 2026 · Read the post
What helpssupereo shows the sample behind every rate, the answer count and the 95% range, so you can see whether a number is settled.
“An AI rank tracker showing only a visibility score or percentage looks scammy to me. I personally don't trust an AI rank checker that does not show me the answers for my target prompt from ChatGPT, Perplexity, Grok, etc.”u/successful1806 on r/localseo · Sep 17, 2026 · Read the post
What helpssupereo shows every answer behind a rate, word for word, with the line that names you.
“The output is non-deterministic, so one run is a single sample from a distribution, not a measurement.”u/marintkael on r/AISearchLab · Jun 29, 2026 · Read the post
A tool that asks AI engines such as ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Mode your prompts and records whether your brand appears and where it falls in the answer. The useful ones also report how often you appear, with a range.
supereo, for most teams: it tracks ChatGPT, Perplexity, AI Mode and three more engines, and reports how often each recommends you, with a range, rather than a rank that changes run to run. ZipTie.ai takes the same rate-first line and charges per check.
One that asks ChatGPT the way buyers do, in the app, signed out, and shows the answers. supereo does both; Peec AI and SE Visible also collect through the interface.
Yes: supereo, ZipTie.ai, Rankscale and Nightwatch cover ChatGPT, Perplexity and AI Mode on their entry plans. Peec AI and Otterly.AI sell one of the two as an add-on.
In one answer, yes; reliably, no one can promise it, because order changes between runs. What you can raise is how often ChatGPT recommends you across your buyers' questions.
Because the answers are generated fresh each time. SparkToro found two runs list the same brands in the same order about once in 1,000. Judge a rate over weeks, not a position on a day.
More: AI Overview trackers compared · Best AI visibility trackers · LLM monitoring tools
Position definitions come from each tracker's docs, glossary or pricing page, read November 8, 2026. The first-named counts are ours, from supereo's November 7 research panel (28 questions, 5 engines, US). The Brand A and B table is an illustration. Quoted posts are copied word for word. Full method.